Let’s face it. Making pies takes a lot of time and effort. You do not want a pie with a soggy bottom. This is why you need the best aluminum pie pan to help you create the best-tasting pie with the perfect texture. A well-cooked pie should be golden brown and delicious, and the only way to do that is by using the best pie baking dish.
A perfectly-baked pie slides right out of the best aluminum pie pan. This is how you know you purchased the right one. The bottom crust should also be evenly browned before you can call your pie a success. In this article, I reviewed seven of the best metal pie plates that you can use in making different kinds of pie.
Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| HFA 30535 Aluminum Pie Pan | This is the best aluminum pie pan for the reasons that it is reliable and can withstand a wide range of temperatures. From a deep freeze to high oven heat, this tray can go both ways. You can always rely on this product in baking an excellent pie. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| Handi-Foil 12″ Aluminum Foil Pie Pan | This product consists of twelve deep and disposable tin plates, which is good enough for a small gathering or a party. Moreover, these are disposable so you can let your visitor take home some of your freshly-baked pies with them. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| Plasticpro 10” Inch Round Deep Tin Foil Pans | The 10-inch Deep Aluminum Pie Pan is good for baking pies for a family. This is also the best aluminum pie pan when it comes to the price. It is very affordable so you can stock a lot of these at home. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan | Fat Daddio’s is a renowned brand when it comes to manufacturing the best bakeware way back in 2006. The aluminum pie pan is designed for professional baking, and also beginners and baker enthusiasts. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| Disposable/Reusable Heavy-Duty Aluminum 6″ Mini Pie Pans | This pie pan is made of disposable aluminum foil and is a lot tougher than the regular aluminum pan. You can reuse the product by hand washing and drying. These are made for smaller pies. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| Pactogo 9″ Disposable Heavy Smooth-Wall Aluminum Foil Pie Pans | This pie pan has a smooth wall and is made with heavy gauge aluminum foil, which makes it thicker and heavier than regular pans. Moreover, the product is reusable with minimal care. It can handle your baking needs, especially during special events and occasions. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. | ||
| KitchenDance Disposable Aluminum Quilted Bottom Pie Pans | KitchenDance quilted bottom pie pans are made of heavier gauge aluminum foil, which means that these are strong enough to handle your baking needs. Moreover, it has a quilted bottom that gives the crust of your pie a nice texture. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market. |
![HFA 30535 Aluminum Pie Pan](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B004NG8QWG&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="HFA 30535 Aluminum Pie Pan" width="500" height="500" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
![Handi-Foil 12" Aluminum Foil Pie Pan](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01JH4HTXU&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="Handi-Foil 12" Aluminum Foil Pie Pan" width="500" height="262" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
![Fat Daddio's Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0017Z5TTY&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="Fat Daddio's Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan" width="500" height="500" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
![Disposable/Reusable Heavy-Duty Aluminum 6" Mini Pie Pans](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00Q51GWXC&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="Disposable/Reusable Heavy-Duty Aluminum 6" Mini Pie Pans" width="500" height="410" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
![Pactogo 9" Disposable Heavy Smooth-Wall Aluminum Foil Pie Pans](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07J2B7GMH&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="Pactogo 9" Disposable Heavy Smooth-Wall Aluminum Foil Pie Pans" width="500" height="216" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
![KitchenDance Disposable Aluminum Quilted Bottom Pie Pans](http://ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/q?_encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07MKPLKS3&Format=_SL500_&ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=bellacupcakecouture-20&language=en_US" alt="KitchenDance Disposable Aluminum Quilted Bottom Pie Pans" width="500" height="251" border="0" draggable="false"></a>)
Best Aluminum Pie Pan Reviews
HFA 30535 Aluminum Pie Pan
This is the best aluminum pie pan for the reasons that it is reliable and can withstand a wide range of temperatures. From a deep freeze to high oven heat, this tray can go both ways. You can always rely on this product in baking an excellent pie. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
HFA Aluminum pie pan has a rigid and durable construction. It also has an exceptional holding power that is good enough for carrying outs, cooking, and serving. Also, the pan is odor and moisture-resistant so you can store it in your kitchen self without hassle. The pan is Easy to clean and reusable. It is truly an economical and reliable brand that you should consider in your next purchase.
The Good
This product is durable enough for regular pie-making. You can even make pies every day with this. That’s how durable it is.
The Bad
The pan is smaller than expected and is too narrow for big servings.
PROs
- Can withstand a wide range of temperatures: from a deep freeze to high oven heat
- Rigid and durable construction
- Odor and moisture-resistant
- Easy to clean and reusable
CONs
- Smaller than expected
- Too narrow
- A bit bent upon arrival
Handi-Foil 12″ Aluminum Foil Pie Pan
This product consists of twelve deep and disposable tin plates, which is good enough for a small gathering or a party. Moreover, these are disposable so you can let your visitor take home some of your freshly-baked pies with them. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
Handi-Foil Aluminum Pan is a large pan, and when I say large, that means you can make as much pie as you want. The product description says that the pots are 12 inches in size, and that is what you will get exactly. Additionally, the aluminum is sturdy enough to avoid spillage. This aluminum pan is truly something you can count on in making big batches of pies.
The Good
You will be amazed by the size of these aluminum pans. If you have lots of visitors, then you should consider buying this.
The Bad
The pans are big enough but too shallow for quiches. Also, you have to be careful in serving the pies since the sides are a bit flimsy.
PROs
- Consists of twelve deep and disposable tin plates
- The aluminum pans are large enough for a big crowd
- Sturdy enough to avoid spillage
- Made with 50 gauge aluminum
CONs
- Too shallow for quiches
- Sides are a bit flimsy
- Not proportional
Plasticpro 10” Inch Round Deep Tin Foil Pans
The Plasticpro 10” Inch Round Deep Tin Foil Pans is good for baking pies for a family. This is also the best aluminum pie pan when it comes to the price. It is very affordable so you can stock a lot of these at home. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
You can now bake delicious dishes with this aluminum pan. It can handle all the ingredients that you have in your recipe. Also, it is very cheap. The fact that it is reusable and washable is also very practical on your part, especially if you are on a tight budget.
The Good
The best part about this product is that aside from its affordability, it is also reusable and washable. That is superb practicality on the part of the user.
The Bad
The packaging is not good since the pans are squeezed into a small bag. Moreover, some of the pans arrived dirty.
PROs
- This 10-inch Deep Aluminum Pie Pan is good for baking pies for a family
- Very affordable so you can stock a lot of these at home
- Can handle all types of ingredients
- Reusable and washable
CONs
- The packaging is not good
- Some of the pans arrived dirty
- Pans are a little shallow
Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan
Fat Daddio’s is a renowned brand when it comes to manufacturing the best bakeware way back in 2006. The aluminum pie pan is designed for professional baking, and also beginners and baker enthusiasts. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
This product has a flat rim design that measures 0.5 inches for professional baking. Also, the aluminum pie pan is 50% deeper than traditional pie pans. This has the ideal baking surface for different kinds of ingredients. You do not have to worry about the durability of this baking pan is it underwent a ‘Safe Seal’ anodizing process to create a more durable and safer baking pan. Moreover, it has a durable and non-reactive finish to bake a variety of recipes. Even Citrus-based products and savory recipes will not deteriorate the material of this aluminum pan.
The Good
If you are in a rush and is running a commercial bakery, you can expect this product to heat and cool the pie quickly. Rather than absorbing heat, it reflects it. You can reach baking temperatures faster and cool quicker when taken out of the oven.
The Bad
The product gets scratches easily, and the size is not as expected.
PROs
- Designed for professional baking
- The ‘Safe-Seal’ anodizing process creates a safer, stronger baking pan
- The durable, non-reactive finish bakes a wider variety of recipes, including citrus-based and savory recipes
- Can reach baking temperatures faster and cool quicker when taken out of the oven
- Lifetime Warranty
CONs
- Gets scratches easily
- Size is not as expected
- Turns brownish when washed
Disposable/Reusable Heavy-Duty Aluminum 6″ Mini Pie Pans
This pie pan is made of disposable aluminum foil and is a lot tougher than the regular aluminum pan. You can reuse the product by hand washing and drying. These are made for smaller pies. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
These mini pie pans are extra wide for making the crust. Also, if you are looking for pans that have individual servings, then this should be your top pick. This is reusable that even when you use a knife to cut into the pie in it, it still won’t damage the bottom part. Moreover, this is the perfect size when you feel like baking a pie just for yourself.
The Good
After making pies, you can easily take out the dish with this aluminum pan. With just a little cooking spray, the food easily comes out without dents or broken crusts.
The Bad
This product is almost perfect, but don’t be misled and read the description carefully. These are mini pie pans that you cannot use for big batches of pies.
PROs
- It’s durable
- Made of disposable aluminum foil
- Extra wide for making the crust
- 100% reusable
- It’s affordable
- Great for individual servings
CONs
- Not for big batches of pies
- A little narrow
- No return policy indicated
Pactogo 9″ Disposable Heavy Smooth-Wall Aluminum Foil Pie Pans
This pie pan has a smooth wall and is made with heavy gauge aluminum foil, which makes it thicker and heavier than regular pans. Moreover, the product is reusable with minimal care. It can handle your baking needs, especially during special events and occasions. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
You can rely on this product’s durability since it is made with heavy 70-gauge disposable aluminum. It comes in a pack of 50 and is good enough for all occasions. Moreover, the pans will not easily crush or bend. It has a very sturdy construction thanks to its materials. Its practicality is also a big asset since you can reuse the pans.
The Good
You can choose to dispose of or reuse these aluminum pans. However, you need to wash and clean the pans thoroughly if you want to reuse them.
The Bad
The packaging is not very good since some of the pans have dents and are thinner than expected.
PROs
- Made with heavy 70 gauge disposable aluminum
- Thicker than standard pie pans
- Will not easily bend, buckle, or crush
- Disposable and reusable
- They are widely used by many high-end bakeries and caterers across America
- Ideal for pies, sweets, Western party themes, outdoor events, barbeque, and more
CONs
- The packaging is not very good
- Thinner than expected
- Not as deep as other pans
KitchenDance Disposable Aluminum Quilted Bottom Pie Pans
KitchenDance quilted bottom pie pans are made of heavier gauge aluminum foil, which means that these are strong enough to handle your baking needs. Moreover, it has a quilted bottom that gives the crust of your pie a nice texture. One of the best aluminum pie pan in the market.
Product Highlights
The size and depth of these pie pans are impressive. These are also very sturdy enough to handle various types of pies. The edges are also perfect for making the crust of the pie a little crispy. Moreover, it is affordable enough if you are on a tight budget.
The Good
Customer service is excellent, and the packaging of the items is also superb. These are also high-quality products that you can entrust your perfectly-baked pies with.
The Bad
The pie pans are 8 inches instead of 9, as described. Also, these are not very deep.
PROs
- Made of heavier gauge aluminum foil
- The size and depth of these pie pans are impressive
- Sturdy enough to handle various types of pies
- Edges are also perfect for making the crust of the pie a little crispy
- Sold at a reasonable price
- Excellent customer service
- Great packaging
CONs
- Wrong product description
- Pans are not very deep
- Not for chunky ingredients
Conclusion
The best aluminum pie pan depends on the type of pie you are trying to make and the size. Make sure that you get the right one by reading the descriptions thoroughly. Some of these are not available in your local retail stores, so it is best to buy them online. These aluminum pie pans are seven of the best and high-rated in the market, so choosing one from the list is definitely worth the bucks. Know more about pie pans.